What's new
  • SNBForums Code of Conduct

    SNBForums is a community for everyone, no matter what their level of experience.

    Please be tolerant and patient of others, especially newcomers. We are all here to share and learn!

    The rules are simple: Be patient, be nice, be helpful or be gone!

A question regarding Aimesh for the gt-be98, and if the gt-be19000 is a better choice? Did I make a good choice in general??

Neco

New Around Here
Hi! I am like very new and new to this forum, and this could probably be a stupid question coming from me, but I am still writing this since I am just unsure. I am from Norway.
I have ordered 2 GT-BE98 routers to replace the mesh system I have at home that the ISP here has provided me for free, 4-5ish years ago. The current setup is 2 airties 4930, and just currently, I got the modem/router upgraded from the ISP to a Wi-Fi 6 capable one (It's a Sagecom F@ST3896). I was thinking of replacing the 2 airties mesh boxes with a new WiFi 7 capable router by using bridge mode on the Sagecom modem/router to handle the connection and have the modem/router as a modem. I am not really sure, but is the GT-BE98 a good choice, or is the GT-BE19000 a better choice because of the two 6GHz bands it has? Since I was thinking of running the Asus routers in Aimesh mode, and I have never used their routers before. My use case is to have my NAS and maybe my Quest 3 be connected to the router, and my PC in my room connected to one of the GT-BE98s to be able to use for streaming VR. I was also planning to stream from my main PC down to the living room TV PC for Moonlight streaming, and in general, a router I can modify myself enough for gaming. (The current setup is very unstable in terms of connection since the Airties boxes sometimes disconnect, and I have to pair them again and again, and it's getting on me now. And just so it's clear, it's a 3-floor house, hence the mesh boxes. One for the 2nd floor and the 3rd floor)
I am not sure how the Aimesh system works, but from what I have read, if I use the wireless backhaul, it will, by default, choose the fastest band. So the 6GHz band will be used by mesh connectivity, and the rest of the band, as the 5GHz and so on, will be free for normal use? And now the question regarding GT-BE19000, since the 98 PRO is not available here in Norway, the GT-BE19000 is the closest thing in terms of how many bands it has. Since the PRO and the 19000 have two 6Ghz bands, wouldn't it be better to have that? I am not sure if the GT-BE98 was a good choice, but I can, of course, send it back if it was indeed a bad choice. I am also not very familiar with firmware, and from reading here, GNUTON and Merlin are some good firmwares to use? If someone here could explain and answer my questions, I have written here, I would be very grateful, since this section of Tech is something I am not really good at, and I never knew I would dabble in it until like now.
 
You made the right choice as the GT-BE19000 has a single 6 GHz, and is only tri-band.

Since the GT-BE98 has two 5 GHz bands I believe it will use 5 GHz-2 for backhaul by default.
 
You made the right choice as the GT-BE19000 has a single 6 GHz, and is only tri-band.

Since the GT-BE98 has two 5 GHz bands I believe it will use 5 GHz-2 for backhaul by default.
Ooh so I did miss a couple points on the GT-BE19000. That's good to know then. Then I am sure the GT-BE98 setup will be perfect for what I am gonna use it for! Thanks for the clarification on that!
Cheers!🍻
 
I am sure the GT-BE98 setup will be perfect

Try first and then decide. Don't miss the return period.

 
Purchasing hardware by specifications alone is often a mistake. In your country you have single 80MHz wide 5GHz channel in non-DFS range, dedicated wireless backhaul in DFS is not guaranteed to work, your 2.4GHz band is limited to 20dBm and 5GHz band in non-DFS to 23dBm. The new to you 6GHz band is short range, shorter than 5GHz band, indoor only. There is a big chance you'll be overpaying for hardware with minimal user experience improvements. Don't invest in short range speed tests.
 
Purchasing hardware by specifications alone is often a mistake. In your country you have single 80MHz wide 5GHz channel in non-DFS range, dedicated wireless backhaul in DFS is not guaranteed to work, your 2.4GHz band is limited to 20dBm and 5GHz band in non-DFS to 23dBm. The new to you 6GHz band is short range, shorter than 5GHz band, indoor only. There is a big chance you'll be overpaying for hardware with minimal user experience improvements. Don't invest in short range speed tests.
Will have to look into that then, thanks for giving me that info. Will still have to test if the routers I ordered will be working as I would think they will. Since last time I tested a WiFi6 router, I was using it for local connectivity for local streaming like my Quest 3 which did indeed work but not exactly at the top spec. (It was an Asus AX18000 RT-AX53U that I bought last year to test with my Quest 3 but didn't quite meet my requirements in terms of performance, which I ended up refunding back to the store since there is an open purchase policy that allows me to test the productand return it as long it's in same condition and with the package it was with)
 
I am not sure how the Aimesh system works
I was thinking of replacing the 2 airties mesh boxes

The moment you replace the ISP provided equipment you become responsible for supporting and troubleshooting your own. You have to solve any issues yourself. If you have no experience with AiMesh - don't do it. Not the best mesh system on the market and not the easiest to manage. It's a constant work in progress ASUS proprietary add-on on top of Broadcom hardware with users as beta testers involved. If you want better set-and-forget mesh experience go for Qualcomm based hardware with built-in SoC/drivers mesh features. If you have no idea what this means - stick to your ISP provided equipment for now and save your money.

not exactly at the top spec

Wi-Fi is convenience technology limited by local environment. Top specs only in specifications with ideal conditions. If you have tried already dedicated Wi-Fi 6 router/AP to your VR set and the result wasn't great - don't expect miracles with more expensive hardware.
 
The moment you replace the ISP provided equipment you become responsible for supporting and troubleshooting your own. You have to solve any issues yourself. If you have no experience with AiMesh - don't do it. Not the best mesh system on the market and not the easiest to manage. It's a constant work in progress ASUS proprietary add-on on top of Broadcom hardware with users as beta testers involved. If you want better set-and-forget mesh experience go for Qualcomm based hardware with built-in SoC/drivers mesh features. If you have no idea what this means - stick to your ISP provided equipment for now and save your money.



Wi-Fi is convenience technology limited by local environment. Top specs only in specifications with ideal conditions. If you have tried already dedicated Wi-Fi 6 router/AP to your VR set and the result wasn't great - don't expect miracles with more expensive hardware.
Noted, I am willing to tinker and troubleshoot on my own will since that's what I had to do anyway with the airties mesh boxes (the setup was weird already enough but not anything dramatic).

Will keep in mind on what you wrote incase the setup is not working out ofc! I am willing to learn this side of tech anyway so it's a good start I guess?
 
If you want performance improvements you have to work towards wired infrastructure first. Wireless mesh is Plan B with no guaranteed performance. Using DFS range for wireless backhaul is relying on luck. Just paying more for high-end home routers is not a solution. They will work with the same environment limitations. Futureproofing ideas with home routers is proven ineffective. Most of the time it's overpaying for specs that may never be actually reached or used. Gaming routers are pure marketing, there is no gaming networking.
 
Noted, I am willing to tinker and troubleshoot on my own will since that's what I had to do anyway with the airties mesh boxes (the setup was weird already enough but not anything dramatic).

Will keep in mind on what you wrote incase the setup is not working out ofc! I am willing to learn this side of tech anyway so it's a good start I guess?
Be sure you've updated to the latest firmware, and factory/hard reset, before you start your setup work....
 
I am willing to tinker

Keep in mind Wi-Fi 7 ASUS routers have broken QoS. If you need QoS for your gaming needs - look for something else. As per trusted source (Asuswrt-Merlin firmware developer) fix is not expected any time soon. The issue comes from broken 3rd party component used in ASUS firmware. Your traffic type recognition may not work reliably as well. You also need to know major Asuswrt features require data sharing agreement to 3rd party company, TrendMicro. If you don't agree to data sharing all AiProtection, Traffic Analyzer (broken), Adaptive QoS (broken), Game Boost (QoS, broken), Web History, Parental Controls, etc. main firmware features will be unavailable.
 
Keep in mind Wi-Fi 7 ASUS routers have broken QoS. If you need QoS for your gaming needs - look for something else. As per trusted source (Asuswrt-Merlin firmware developer) fix is not expected any time soon. The issue comes from broken 3rd party component used in ASUS firmware. Your traffic type recognition may not work reliably as well. You also need to know major Asuswrt features require data sharing agreement to 3rd party company, TrendMicro. If you don't agree to data sharing all AiProtection, Traffic Analyzer (broken), Adaptive QoS (broken), Game Boost (QoS, broken), Web History, Parental Controls, etc. main firmware features will be unavailable.
Noted
 

Latest threads

Support SNBForums w/ Amazon

If you'd like to support SNBForums, just use this link and buy anything on Amazon. Thanks!

Sign Up For SNBForums Daily Digest

Get an update of what's new every day delivered to your mailbox. Sign up here!

Members online

Back
Top