What's new

ZenWifi or Deco?

digital10

Regular Contributor
I am looking for any one with real life experience with ZenWifi . I am up to buy a new mesh system and I am between Zenwifi, Deco, and Orbi. I am most looking for rock stability and no disconnections over maximum speeds.

Can any one advice if zenwifi has any superiority over the other 2? is it worse? The deco requires an online account to manage and an app (which I hate) and Orbi are going crazt with some routers reaching prices of $1500+ . Any sort of guidance is appreciated.
 
i believe the Deco have Qualcomm radios. Don't know about ASUS for sure, but they use a lot of Broadcom chips. i recall a post by @Tech9 that listed who had what, but i am not finding it.

Go with whoever has the Qualcomm chips and meets your budget would be my choice.
 
found the post

 
i believe the Deco have Qualcomm radios. Don't know about ASUS for sure, but they use a lot of Broadcom chips. i recall a post by @Tech9 that listed who had what, but i am not finding it.

Go with whoever has the Qualcomm chips and meets your budget would be my choice.

whats special about qualcomm chips?
 
I had an Orbi system about 4 years ago (RBR850 + 2x RBS850). Did not like it. Clunky GUI, difficult to configure the way I wanted --- not least because it required a full reboot after even minor config changes. Required cloud management, which was free but still meant Netgear had control over my system. The last straw was when an overnight firmware update bricked the base router. I don't believe in automatic system updates, but with this gear you do not have control of that.

Maybe they've fixed some of those things since then, but I wouldn't bet on it.

I then went to ASUS (ZenWifi XT8 units), which were great when they worked but had an awful lot of problems with firmware bugs and instability.

Since then I've used Zyxel and UniFi gear, which I've liked, but they are more oriented to business than consumer use: they require a moderate amount of wifi+networking knowledge to configure correctly.

Don't have any personal experience with Deco. But my take on this is that everything in this product space has its pluses and minuses; there's no best-for-everyone product.
 
Be careful when buying anything TP-Link when it comes to routers, they tend release a handful of firmware updates at the most, then make a new hardware revision and drop support for the older hardware revision(s).

Not saying Asus is perfect here, far from it, as you need to check which models they do regular updates for here as well, since some models/SKUs are not well supported, whereas others have been seeing updates for a decade.

Same with Netgear, some products like the Nighthawk R7800 has seen close to a decade of updates, other products got dropped after a year or two.

From a hardware perspective, are you going to use wireless or wired backhaul? If you're going to use wireless, you want models with three or four radios and those cost a small fortune, regardless of brand. If you only get two radios, then the 5 GHz radio will be doing split duty between backhaul and dealing with your devices, which imho isn't a good idea. If you got wired backhaul, a dual radio device is fine, just make sure wired backhaul is supported.

It's in other words not a matter of a specific brand being better or not, but rather the features on offer by the product itself and whether or not it gets regular software updates, which is really something you want this day in age where new security issues is found on a regular basis.

I used two routers (different brands) and range extender, with the RE and one router set up as wireless access points with wired backhaul and I had no issues roaming between the three units, all using the same SSID. Your milage may vary though and I'm not saying this was the ideal setup, but I also set it up before consumer mesh setups was a "thing" and it worked fine for over half a dozen years.
 
Last edited:
I had an Orbi system about 4 years ago (RBR850 + 2x RBS850). Did not like it. Clunky GUI, difficult to configure the way I wanted --- not least because it required a full reboot after even minor config changes. Required cloud management, which was free but still meant Netgear had control over my system. The last straw was when an overnight firmware update bricked the base router. I don't believe in automatic system updates, but with this gear you do not have control of that.

Maybe they've fixed some of those things since then, but I wouldn't bet on it.

I then went to ASUS (ZenWifi XT8 units), which were great when they worked but had an awful lot of problems with firmware bugs and instability.

Since then I've used Zyxel and UniFi gear, which I've liked, but they are more oriented to business than consumer use: they require a moderate amount of wifi+networking knowledge to configure correctly.

Don't have any personal experience with Deco. But my take on this is that everything in this product space has its pluses and minuses; there's no best-for-everyone product.

what would be unifi equivilant of mesh system? i know they have their alien hd router but seems expensive and they do not seem serious about it
 
Be careful when buying anything TP-Link when it comes to routers, they tend release a handful of firmware updates at the most, then make a new hardware revision and drop support for the older hardware revision(s).

Not saying Asus is perfect here, far from it, as you need to check which models they do regular updates for here as well, since some models/SKUs are not well supported, whereas others have been seeing updates for a decade.

Same with Netgear, some products like the Nighthawk R7800 has seen close to a decade of updates, other products got dropped after a year or two.

From a hardware perspective, are you going to use wireless or wired backhaul? If you're going to use wireless, you want models with three or four radios and those cost a small fortune, regardless of brand. If you only get two radios, then the 5 GHz radio will be doing split duty between backhaul and dealing with your devices, which imho isn't a good idea. If you got wired backhaul, a dual radio device is fine, just make sure wired backhaul is supported.

It's in other words not a matter of a specific brand being better or not, but rather the features on offer by the product itself and whether or not it gets regular software updates, which is really something you want this day in age where new security issues is found on a regular basis.

I used two routers (different brands) and range extender, with the RE and one router set up as wireless access points with wired backhaul and I had no issues roaming between the three units, all using the same SSID. Your milage may vary though and I'm not saying this was the ideal setup, but I also set it up before consumer mesh setups was a "thing" and it worked fine for over half a dozen years.

tell me about it, i got 5g CPE from TP Link for like $500 a couple years ago and they seem to have us left in the dust with firmware upgrades.

I wanted to go with Asus but firmware bugs is scaring me as network stability is most important factor here. My choices are thinning into getting an orbi again albeit i feel like i am going to pay a crazy price.
 
Any sort of guidance is appreciated.

I can't provide any guidance based on zero information about use case and expectations.

what would be unifi equivilant of mesh system? i know they have their alien hd router

Ubiquiti doesn't have Alien product in UniFi line of products. Seems like you haven't done even basic research and expect someone to offer you matching product for your unknown application. For maximum reliability - wired infrastructure first and we go from there. Anything wireless is Plan B and conditional.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
C TP Link Deco X50-PoE vs Aruba AP22 Wi-Fi Buying Advice 0

Similar threads

Support SNBForums w/ Amazon

If you'd like to support SNBForums, just use this link and buy anything on Amazon. Thanks!

Sign Up For SNBForums Daily Digest

Get an update of what's new every day delivered to your mailbox. Sign up here!
Back
Top