What's new
  • SNBForums Code of Conduct

    SNBForums is a community for everyone, no matter what their level of experience.

    Please be tolerant and patient of others, especially newcomers. We are all here to share and learn!

    The rules are simple: Be patient, be nice, be helpful or be gone!

Apple: "Limited Compatibility" of separate network names per band?

onesus

New Around Here
Just upgraded from RT-AC86U to GT-BE98 Pro. As was my custom with the old router on the new one I assigned SSID names that include a band designation. On Mac mini M4 Pro, macOS System Settings for Wi-Fi shows connection to one of the two 6GHz bands. The Details button shows this warning: "Limited Compatibility / This network is configured with a separate network name for 6GHz, which may impact some experiences like AirPlay. If this is your Wi-Fi network, configure the router to use a single network name for all bands." Then there's a "Learn more..." link: Recommended settings for Wi-Fi routers and access points.

The linked page says, "Make sure that all routers on your network use the same name for every band they support. If you give your 2.4 GHz, 5 GHz, or 6 GHz bands different names, devices might not connect reliably to your network, to all routers on your network, or to all available bands of your routers. If your router is providing a Wi-Fi 6E network that isn't using the same name for all bands, Apple devices that support Wi-Fi 6E will identify the network as having limited compatibility." The page links to yet another page, Use Wi-Fi 6E networks with Apple devices that says, "If the router isn’t using the same name for all bands, your device identifies the network as having limited compatibility. It then finds the name of the corresponding 5 GHz network and asks whether you want to join it for better compatibility" And in the spirit of vagueness already established: "If you select Not Now, your device continues to use the Wi-Fi 6E network, but your overall experience with some activities over the network might not be as expected."

It's not clear to me that this warning and advice applies to my single-router network. Also, I have no idea how, if all bands have the same name, a device determines which one to connect to. Currently, based on habit formed using the RT-AC68U, I choose the band from the SSIDs shown as available with each SSID name indicating its band.

Despite my having a "Pro" router and a "Pro" Apple Silicon CPU, I'm not a pro with respect to networking.
 
Just upgraded from RT-AC86U to GT-BE98 Pro. As was my custom with the old router on the new one I assigned SSID names that include a band designation. On Mac mini M4 Pro, macOS System Settings for Wi-Fi shows connection to one of the two 6GHz bands. The Details button shows this warning: "Limited Compatibility / This network is configured with a separate network name for 6GHz, which may impact some experiences like AirPlay. If this is your Wi-Fi network, configure the router to use a single network name for all bands." Then there's a "Learn more..." link: Recommended settings for Wi-Fi routers and access points.

The linked page says, "Make sure that all routers on your network use the same name for every band they support. If you give your 2.4 GHz, 5 GHz, or 6 GHz bands different names, devices might not connect reliably to your network, to all routers on your network, or to all available bands of your routers. If your router is providing a Wi-Fi 6E network that isn't using the same name for all bands, Apple devices that support Wi-Fi 6E will identify the network as having limited compatibility." The page links to yet another page, Use Wi-Fi 6E networks with Apple devices that says, "If the router isn’t using the same name for all bands, your device identifies the network as having limited compatibility. It then finds the name of the corresponding 5 GHz network and asks whether you want to join it for better compatibility" And in the spirit of vagueness already established: "If you select Not Now, your device continues to use the Wi-Fi 6E network, but your overall experience with some activities over the network might not be as expected."

It's not clear to me that this warning and advice applies to my single-router network. Also, I have no idea how, if all bands have the same name, a device determines which one to connect to. Currently, based on habit formed using the RT-AC68U, I choose the band from the SSIDs shown as available with each SSID name indicating its band.

Despite my having a "Pro" router and a "Pro" Apple Silicon CPU, I'm not a pro with respect to networking.
Just go back to using the SmartConnect feature with a single SSID for all bands and let the router and clients figure out which band they want to connect to. If you want a separate SSID for something set up a guest WIFI.
Your router and Mac Book know more about modern WIFI than you do. Best to not second guess them...
 
Just go back to using the SmartConnect feature with a single SSID for all bands and let the router and clients figure out which band they want to connect to. If you want a separate SSID for something set up a guest WIFI.
Your router and Mac Book know more about modern WIFI than you do. Best to not second guess them...
OK... BBBBut I can't find a `Smart Connect` setting anywhere. It's not where the User Manual says it is, nor in either of the two Web UI places (depending on firmware version) that the ASUS FAQ describes on How to configure the Smart Connect in ASUS Router? I'm running Merlin, as I always have. Doesn't seem likely that would do away with Smart Connect, but I dunno.

Related note: I currently have the 2.4GHz and 5GHz SSID names the same as they were on the old router, with the same passwords. All the devices, including some ancient ones, automagically connected to the BD98. If I succeed in using just one SSID, will I have to individually access the UI of each of a bunch of devices to connect them?

Edit to add: Via the User Manual I found a Network Rules :: Smart Connect Rule tab but (a) it appears to assume Smart Connect is already on, and (b) the various available rule criteria are beyond my ken.
 
Last edited:

Support SNBForums w/ Amazon

If you'd like to support SNBForums, just use this link and buy anything on Amazon. Thanks!

Sign Up For SNBForums Daily Digest

Get an update of what's new every day delivered to your mailbox. Sign up here!

Staff online

Members online

Back
Top