Thanks ColinTaylor. Duh! I really should have though of that myself. It does appear though that if you are working w/ VLANs the router supplying the WAN needs to be VLAN capable. I tried using an old Belkin (10+ years old) as the dummy WAN and did not work but did when I put it at the "end of the line" and a VLAN capable Buffalo as the dummy WAN.
As I am trying to learn how to setup managed switches, VLANs, OpenWrt x86, subnetworks; this will give me a WAN to ping test without having to connect to my ISP and shutdown the internet for the rest of the house. So yes, coxhaus, I have been seeking advice on specifics.
I know this setup won't guarantee that I can browse the internet without issue (as coxhaus is probably thinking) but I did come across WANEM. This would probably be capable of creating a dummy internet to test just about everything, but then I would have to learn how to use WANEM, and that is more than I want to get into.
Thanks a lot to everyone for taking a look at this. The family is much less annoyed w/ me now.