The username-as-common-name directive doesn't appear correct. The separator does NOT look like a normal dash (-) character. Or perhaps that's just an artifact of the screen capture.
Also, why are there *two* instances of the OpenVPN server? Seems to me based on your initial post there should be only *one*.
It doesn't help either that you obscured the Common Name field. Each client has to be uniquely identified by different usernames, which correspond to how you configured Manage Client-Specific Options. You can always change the username(s) later. But for diagnostic purposes, you're making things more difficult.