What's new

Hard drive keeps giving error

  • SNBForums Code of Conduct

    SNBForums is a community for everyone, no matter what their level of experience.

    Please be tolerant and patient of others, especially newcomers. We are all here to share and learn!

    The rules are simple: Be patient, be nice, be helpful or be gone!

hellreturn

Occasional Visitor
Hello,

I recently update from ASUS firmware to Merlin 384.8-Beta2. It seems external hard drive which is brand new keeps throwing error. I run check and so far no error is reported.

I tried to revert back to default ASUS firmware and below doesn't happen. Any idea how to resolve the issue? - Thanks

PS - Hard drive is brand new and have only may be 100 files on it.

Code:
ntfsck 3014.5.21
Checking NTFS Superblock ...
Device name        : /dev/sda1
NTFS volume version: 3.1
Cluster size       : 4096 bytes
Current volume size: 8001560769024 bytes (8001561 MB)
Current device size: 8001560772608 bytes (8001561 MB)
Checking for bad sectors ...
Scanning $MFT ...
Checking directory structure ...
Checking for orphaned files ...
  0.00 percent completed
  1.12 percent completed
  2.23 percent completed
  3.35 percent completed
  4.46 percent completed
  5.58 percent completed
  6.70 percent completed
  7.81 percent completed
  8.93 percent completed
 10.05 percent completed
 11.16 percent completed
 12.28 percent completed
 13.39 percent completed
 14.51 percent completed
 15.63 percent completed
 16.74 percent completed
 17.86 percent completed
 18.98 percent completed
 20.09 percent completed
 21.21 percent completed
 22.32 percent completed
 23.44 percent completed
 24.56 percent completed
 25.67 percent completed
 26.79 percent completed
 27.90 percent completed
 29.02 percent completed
 30.14 percent completed
 31.25 percent completed
 32.37 percent completed
 33.49 percent completed
 34.60 percent completed
 35.72 percent completed
 36.83 percent completed
 37.95 percent completed
 39.07 percent completed
 40.18 percent completed
 41.30 percent completed
 42.42 percent completed
 43.53 percent completed
 44.65 percent completed
 45.76 percent completed
 46.88 percent completed
 48.00 percent completed
 49.11 percent completed
 50.23 percent completed
 51.35 percent completed
 52.46 percent completed
 53.58 percent completed
 54.69 percent completed
 55.81 percent completed
 56.93 percent completed
 58.04 percent completed
 59.16 percent completed
 60.27 percent completed
 61.39 percent completed
 62.51 percent completed
 63.62 percent completed
 64.74 percent completed
 65.86 percent completed
 66.97 percent completed
 68.09 percent completed
 69.20 percent completed
 70.32 percent completed
 71.44 percent completed
 72.55 percent completed
 73.67 percent completed
 74.79 percent completed
 75.90 percent completed
 77.02 percent completed
 78.13 percent completed
 79.25 percent completed
 80.37 percent completed
 81.48 percent completed
 82.60 percent completed
 83.71 percent completed
 84.83 percent completed
 85.95 percent completed
 87.06 percent completed
 88.18 percent completed
 89.30 percent completed
 90.41 percent completed
 91.53 percent completed
 92.64 percent completed
 93.76 percent completed
 94.88 percent completed
 95.99 percent completed
 97.11 percent completed
 98.23 percent completed
 99.34 percent completed
100.00 percent completed
Scanning orphaned files completed.
Checking attributes ...
  0.00 percent completed
  1.12 percent completed
  2.23 percent completed
  3.35 percent completed
  4.46 percent completed
  5.58 percent completed
  6.70 percent completed
  7.81 percent completed
  8.93 percent completed
 10.05 percent completed
 11.16 percent completed
 12.28 percent completed
 13.39 percent completed
 14.51 percent completed
 15.63 percent completed
 16.74 percent completed
 17.86 percent completed
 18.98 percent completed
 20.09 percent completed
 21.21 percent completed
 22.32 percent completed
 23.44 percent completed
 24.56 percent completed
 25.67 percent completed
 26.79 percent completed
 27.90 percent completed
 29.02 percent completed
 30.14 percent completed
 31.25 percent completed
 32.37 percent completed
 33.49 percent completed
 34.60 percent completed
 35.72 percent completed
 36.83 percent completed
 37.95 percent completed
 39.07 percent completed
 40.18 percent completed
 41.30 percent completed
 42.42 percent completed
 43.53 percent completed
 44.65 percent completed
 45.76 percent completed
 46.88 percent completed
 48.00 percent completed
 49.11 percent completed
 50.23 percent completed
 51.35 percent completed
 52.46 percent completed
 53.58 percent completed
 54.69 percent completed
 55.81 percent completed
 56.93 percent completed
 58.04 percent completed
 59.16 percent completed
 60.27 percent completed
 61.39 percent completed
 62.51 percent completed
 63.62 percent completed
 64.74 percent completed
 65.86 percent completed
 66.97 percent completed
 68.09 percent completed
 69.20 percent completed
 70.32 percent completed
 71.44 percent completed
 72.55 percent completed
 73.67 percent completed
 74.79 percent completed
 75.90 percent completed
 77.02 percent completed
 78.13 percent completed
 79.25 percent completed
 80.37 percent completed
 81.48 percent completed
 82.60 percent completed
 83.71 percent completed
 84.83 percent completed
 85.95 percent completed
 87.06 percent completed
 88.18 percent completed
 89.30 percent completed
 90.41 percent completed
 91.53 percent completed
 92.64 percent completed
 93.76 percent completed
 94.88 percent completed
 95.99 percent completed
 97.11 percent completed
 98.23 percent completed
 99.34 percent completed
100.00 percent completed
Failed to calloc 244188256 bytes: Cannot allocate memory
Checking cluster allocation ...
ERROR(12): Failed to setup allocation bitmap: Cannot allocate memory
Syncing device ...
 
Hello,

I recently update from ASUS firmware to Merlin 384.8-Beta2. It seems external hard drive which is brand new keeps throwing error. I run check and so far no error is reported.

I tried to revert back to default ASUS firmware and below doesn't happen. Any idea how to resolve the issue? - Thanks

PS - Hard drive is brand new and have only may be 100 files on it.

Code:
ntfsck 3014.5.21
Checking NTFS Superblock ...
Device name        : /dev/sda1
NTFS volume version: 3.1
Cluster size       : 4096 bytes
Current volume size: 8001560769024 bytes (8001561 MB)
Current device size: 8001560772608 bytes (8001561 MB)
Checking for bad sectors ...
Scanning $MFT ...
Checking directory structure ...
Checking for orphaned files ...
  0.00 percent completed
  1.12 percent completed
  2.23 percent completed
  3.35 percent completed
  4.46 percent completed
  5.58 percent completed
  6.70 percent completed
  7.81 percent completed
  8.93 percent completed
 10.05 percent completed
 11.16 percent completed
 12.28 percent completed
 13.39 percent completed
 14.51 percent completed
 15.63 percent completed
 16.74 percent completed
 17.86 percent completed
 18.98 percent completed
 20.09 percent completed
 21.21 percent completed
 22.32 percent completed
 23.44 percent completed
 24.56 percent completed
 25.67 percent completed
 26.79 percent completed
 27.90 percent completed
 29.02 percent completed
 30.14 percent completed
 31.25 percent completed
 32.37 percent completed
 33.49 percent completed
 34.60 percent completed
 35.72 percent completed
 36.83 percent completed
 37.95 percent completed
 39.07 percent completed
 40.18 percent completed
 41.30 percent completed
 42.42 percent completed
 43.53 percent completed
 44.65 percent completed
 45.76 percent completed
 46.88 percent completed
 48.00 percent completed
 49.11 percent completed
 50.23 percent completed
 51.35 percent completed
 52.46 percent completed
 53.58 percent completed
 54.69 percent completed
 55.81 percent completed
 56.93 percent completed
 58.04 percent completed
 59.16 percent completed
 60.27 percent completed
 61.39 percent completed
 62.51 percent completed
 63.62 percent completed
 64.74 percent completed
 65.86 percent completed
 66.97 percent completed
 68.09 percent completed
 69.20 percent completed
 70.32 percent completed
 71.44 percent completed
 72.55 percent completed
 73.67 percent completed
 74.79 percent completed
 75.90 percent completed
 77.02 percent completed
 78.13 percent completed
 79.25 percent completed
 80.37 percent completed
 81.48 percent completed
 82.60 percent completed
 83.71 percent completed
 84.83 percent completed
 85.95 percent completed
 87.06 percent completed
 88.18 percent completed
 89.30 percent completed
 90.41 percent completed
 91.53 percent completed
 92.64 percent completed
 93.76 percent completed
 94.88 percent completed
 95.99 percent completed
 97.11 percent completed
 98.23 percent completed
 99.34 percent completed
100.00 percent completed
Scanning orphaned files completed.
Checking attributes ...
  0.00 percent completed
  1.12 percent completed
  2.23 percent completed
  3.35 percent completed
  4.46 percent completed
  5.58 percent completed
  6.70 percent completed
  7.81 percent completed
  8.93 percent completed
 10.05 percent completed
 11.16 percent completed
 12.28 percent completed
 13.39 percent completed
 14.51 percent completed
 15.63 percent completed
 16.74 percent completed
 17.86 percent completed
 18.98 percent completed
 20.09 percent completed
 21.21 percent completed
 22.32 percent completed
 23.44 percent completed
 24.56 percent completed
 25.67 percent completed
 26.79 percent completed
 27.90 percent completed
 29.02 percent completed
 30.14 percent completed
 31.25 percent completed
 32.37 percent completed
 33.49 percent completed
 34.60 percent completed
 35.72 percent completed
 36.83 percent completed
 37.95 percent completed
 39.07 percent completed
 40.18 percent completed
 41.30 percent completed
 42.42 percent completed
 43.53 percent completed
 44.65 percent completed
 45.76 percent completed
 46.88 percent completed
 48.00 percent completed
 49.11 percent completed
 50.23 percent completed
 51.35 percent completed
 52.46 percent completed
 53.58 percent completed
 54.69 percent completed
 55.81 percent completed
 56.93 percent completed
 58.04 percent completed
 59.16 percent completed
 60.27 percent completed
 61.39 percent completed
 62.51 percent completed
 63.62 percent completed
 64.74 percent completed
 65.86 percent completed
 66.97 percent completed
 68.09 percent completed
 69.20 percent completed
 70.32 percent completed
 71.44 percent completed
 72.55 percent completed
 73.67 percent completed
 74.79 percent completed
 75.90 percent completed
 77.02 percent completed
 78.13 percent completed
 79.25 percent completed
 80.37 percent completed
 81.48 percent completed
 82.60 percent completed
 83.71 percent completed
 84.83 percent completed
 85.95 percent completed
 87.06 percent completed
 88.18 percent completed
 89.30 percent completed
 90.41 percent completed
 91.53 percent completed
 92.64 percent completed
 93.76 percent completed
 94.88 percent completed
 95.99 percent completed
 97.11 percent completed
 98.23 percent completed
 99.34 percent completed
100.00 percent completed
Failed to calloc 244188256 bytes: Cannot allocate memory
Checking cluster allocation ...
ERROR(12): Failed to setup allocation bitmap: Cannot allocate memory
Syncing device ...
Did you reset to factory defaults when you upgraded and had problems?
 
Hello,

Yes, i reset to factory defaults after the upgrade and added the hard drive. Below are the steps i followed -

1. Update firmware
2. Did factory reset.
3. Reboot.
4. Configure all from scratch
5. Plugin hard drive.

I even checked hard drive, through smartcl and so far no issues in hard drive. I am also not sure why HD is detected as USB 2.0 and not 3.0.


https://www.screencast.com/t/KDERFXimlC0
 
Hello,

Yes, i reset to factory defaults after the upgrade and added the hard drive. Below are the steps i followed -

1. Update firmware
2. Did factory reset.
3. Reboot.
4. Configure all from scratch
5. Plugin hard drive.

I even checked hard drive, through smartcl and so far no issues in hard drive. I am also not sure why HD is detected as USB 2.0 and not 3.0.


https://www.screencast.com/t/KDERFXimlC0
The disk check on the router is not very good. Install amtm and use the disk check script. It runs at boot.
 
How big is the drive? It won't mount as USB3 because it is not a supported device, (There are very few).
 
Also I don't think that there is support for over 4T drives. Sometimes the drive has to be formatted as ext4 to get everything working.
 
There simply isn't enough memory to support a disk check of an 8TB drive. You would likely also have problems on the OEM firmware as well at some point. You might try partitioning it into 2x4TB drives.
 
The disk check on the router is not very good. Install amtm and use the disk check script. It runs at boot.

I used smartctl which I use for my servers having HD's in RAID and it runs just fine. I even tried WD tool for checking any error. No issues so far.

Also I don't think that there is support for over 4T drives. Sometimes the drive has to be formatted as ext4 to get everything working.

In ASUS default firmware it was listed under USB 3.0. Only with Merlin firmware, I am having issue. So trying to figure out what the issue is.

OEM software's, i have no issue. smartcl runs fine with 10TB hard drives.

My connection to devices is rock solid much better then ASUS firmware. All my smart devices, don't loose any connections but external hard drive is giving me crazy headache.
 

Latest threads

Sign Up For SNBForums Daily Digest

Get an update of what's new every day delivered to your mailbox. Sign up here!
Top