@Jack-Sparr0w ... I don't think this was very necessary to comment on, and find it borderline rude.
@Adamm has poured a ton of his own free time into this new version along with the recent fixes he has been faithfully publishing as he knocks out the various issues. You might want to find ways to express your frustrations in other ways, or elsewhere, so we don't have to see it.
@Viktor Jaep I get where you’re coming from, and I agree that taking cheap shots at Adamm or the project doesn’t help anyone. He’s clearly put a huge amount of his own time and energy into v8, and you can see he’s been working hard to track reports and push out fixes quickly. That deserves a lot of appreciation.
At the same time, I also understand why some people are pretty wound up right now. For a number of us, updating to v8 hasn’t just been “a few rough edges” – it’s been lost access, broken configs, or having to scramble over SSH to recover the router. Most people don’t follow every post in these threads, they just update from amtm and expect “stable” to mean it’s safe for their setup. When that goes sideways, the natural reaction is “you broke my router”, and the frustration level jumps for both the user and the dev.
That’s where I think the process might have gone a bit off the rails. v8 is clearly a massive rewrite and a big step forward overall, but maybe it moved to the main/stable path a little too quickly. Right now, it feels like the community is being asked to be live beta testers on their production routers, whether they meant to volunteer or not. That’s not really fair to casual users, and it also piles even more pressure on Adamm to firefight urgent breakages.
One constructive way forward might be to revert the main branch back to 7.6.5 for the time being, and clearly label v8 as beta/dev again. That would give everyone a known-good baseline while still letting those of us who are willing to test v8 opt in and help shake out the remaining issues. With a bit more time and feedback across different routers, blocklists, and configs, v8 can reach the point where “stable” really means stable for the vast majority of setups.
None of this is meant as a knock on Adamm’s work – quite the opposite. He’s done a commendable job responding to reports and pushing out fixes at a pace that most commercial vendors would never match. It’s more about protecting his time and sanity, and setting expectations so people don’t feel like they got burned for just keeping their systems up to date.
So, in short: v8 looks very promising, and I’m sure it’ll be rock solid in time. But I think it would be healthier for everyone if 7.6.5 was restored as the default “safe” release, and v8 continued as an opt-in beta until it’s proven across a wider range of configurations.