Possible? Yes.
Recommended? No.
Fully update the new router to the firmware you want to use/try. Perform a full reset (be sure you use the 'Initialize all settings...' button in the GUI, and/or also perform the WPS Button reset too, see the link below for the specific instructions for your model router).
Now, minimally and manually configure the new router. Do not use an old backup config file. Do not plug in a USB drive that was previously used for amtm/scripts, without first inserting it into a PC and formatting as NTFS.
Create screenshots of each page of your customized settings on your current/old router. Better yet, saving as a PDF will let you capture the full page in a single save (see the options that Firefox offers when saving webpages as PDFs). A PDF will also allow you to copy/paste easily (unlike a screenshot).
And I still haven't captured all current settings in screenshots.... Any tips on how to do that efficient (in Firefox), especially with pages that requires scrolling? I use Ditto Clipboard Manager. I log into Merlin GUI and press F11 (to expand the view) and just systematically go through...
www.snbforums.com
You can also dump the (sorted) NVRAM too, for reference.
You can use various utilities to backup/restore various parts of the old configuration too.
Better Search, at the top of every page, is your friend here.